Vladimir Ermolaev, Aleksandr Putintsev, Igor Mamalimov and Sergey Kirilyuk with their spouses outside the courthouse

Unjust Verdicts

Appeal in Chita Affirms Harsh Sentence for Jehovah's Witnesses: Six Years in Prison for Three of Them and Six Years Suspended for One

Trans-Baikal Territory

On September 20, 2022 the panel of judges of the Trans-Baikal Territory Court headed by Olga Dedyukhina confirmed the sentence to for four of Jehovah's Witnesses in Chita: Vladimir Ermolaev and Aleksandr Putintsev - 6.5 years of a penal colony, Igor Mamalimov - 6 years in a penal colony, Sergey Kirilyuk - 6 years suspended. The verdict of the lower court came into force.

All four still insist on their innocence. Addressing the court, Aleksandr Putintsev said: "Expression of hatred, hostility and violence is incompatible with my views. I respect representatives of other religions and nationalities. I was convicted only for my belief in God. Igor Mamalimov expressed a similar thought: "I exercise my constitutional right to believe in Jehovah God and live in harmony with my religious beliefs. And it is not a crime. Vladimir Ermolaev reminded that the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation did not ban the religion of Jehovah's Witnesses, and Sergei Kirilyuk concluded: "I am a victim of discrimination... There were no signs of extremism in my actions, which is confirmed by transcripts of audio recordings of worship services and expert conclusions. Moreover, this is confirmed by the witnesses for the prosecution who were questioned.

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation did not require the followers of the Jehovah's Witnesses religion to renounce their faith. And according to Article 13 of the Russian Constitution, the state system of Russia is aimed at protecting the ideological diversity, the principle of secular state and, above all, human rights and freedoms, which are proclaimed as the highest value. However, law enforcement agencies continue to erroneously equate the peaceful religious activity of believers with extremism.

Case of Ermolaev and Others in Chita

Case History
Vladimir Ermolaev, Aleksandr Putintsev, Sergey Kirilyuk and Igor Mamalimov faced prosecution for their faith in 2020, when security forces carried out 50 searches in Chita and other cities in Transbaikalia. During the raid, several believers were detained and two were tortured. Mamalimov, Kirilyuk and Ermolaev were placed in a temporary detention facility, where they spent several days. At some point, four more believers were suspects in the case, but their criminal prosecution was discontinued. For holding peaceful religious services, the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation accused Ermolaev, Putintsev, Mamalimov and Kirilyuk of organizing the activity of an extremist organization. Despite the fact that there were no victims in the case and there was no evidence of crimes against the state and the individual, in 2022 the court sentenced Vladimir Ermolaev, Aleksandr Putintsev and Igor Mamalimov to imprisonment in a penal colony for 6 to 6.5 years, and Sergey Kirilyuk - to 6 years suspended. The court of appeal upheld this verdict. The courts of appeal and cassation did not change this verdict.
Timeline

Persons in case

Criminal case

Region:
Trans-Baikal Territory
Locality:
Chita
Suspected of:
According to the investigation, he "took active organizational actions ... expressed in the organization of meetings, the organization of religious speeches and worship ... fundraising under the guise of donations... involvement of new participants... by carrying out the preaching work."
Court case number:
12002760023000001
Initiated:
January 20, 2020
Current case stage:
The verdict entered into force
Investigating:
Investigative Directorate of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation for the Trans-Baikal Territory
Articles of Criminal Code of Russian Federation:
282.2 (1)
Court case number:
1-10/2022
Court of First Instance:
Центральный районный суд г. Читы
Judge of the Court of First Instance:
Марина Куклина
[i18n] Гособвинитель:
Ковыльченко Д. Г.
Case History